Nano – Tata’s promise fulfilled



The famous words, that will go down in history as golden words from Mr. Ratan Tata. Ending all speculation the Rs.1 Lakh car was launched at Delhi Auto Expo.

It meets Euro 4 emission norms, runs 20 Km in a litre, has passed front and side crash tests.But where will all these additional cars go? The streets of every Indian city are already at gridlock with the rickshaws, marutis, santro and goods vehicles. India needs to upgrade its infrastructure, and enforce some sort of highway code, before unleashing millions of new vehicles onto its roads.

Millions of additional cars is a tough question, yes. I don’t know the answers, but…

Will this more fuel efficient car replace many existing cars on the road?
Will it kill the second hand market for other makes and make them so cheap that more two wheeler owners will buy cars now?
Should’nt we be penalising larger cars and SUVs (maybe with higher taxes) rather than blaming the Tatas?
Will this take off in the rural areas?
Tatas are talking about exporting this in the future. What will it do worldwide?

The only answer I know is to where will these additional cars go?

Nowhere, they will add to the gridlock in many cities.

I find the whole price issue interesting, though, as the reality is that is has never been “cheaper” to own a car in India than today. Most of the new cars on the road in India weren’t paid for in cash but are financed. Many of the car loans available today are terribly easy to get sucked into, with little to no money down, and pushy car dealers eager to earn bank commissions. In this atmosphere, what will be the role of the “1 lakh” car? Will it enable families who can afford the price tag to finally get their first four-wheeler, or will it plunge even poorer families into the murky world of debt otherwise known as car finance?

The issue has no straight-forward answer, but the other factor that has led to the massive increase in vehicles on the roads in India is the artificially low price of fuel due to gov’t regulation in the country. There are populist reasons for keeping the price of fuel low, but the economic and environmental reprocussions are unavoidable.

So address these twin issues (car finance and fuel pricing) and it will solve a huge chunk of India’s congestion and pollution problem

By the way, since the production lines that Maruti is using for 800 are more than couple of decades old, and taking into account the depreciation and sheer production numbers, each car costs only Rs.97,000 to the company.

Ratan Tata may end up being the Henry Ford of our generation. However, the fatal flaw in the car is obvious. Any average indian pothole will bring this car, with its SMALL WHEELS, to a grinding halt!


3 thoughts on “Nano – Tata’s promise fulfilled

  1. yes, every one’s raising the question- whr will all these cars on road lead us to? I think tata’s have done their work in providing what masses need. we should not blame them. what they hav done is splendid. it is govt who needs to decide on infrastructure & environment. india doen;t need lotsa cars/2 wheelers on the road. we need efficient public transport system.

  2. Mr. Ratan Tata deserves all the compliments in creating a
    dream car which can be afforded by the current owners of
    motor cycles. Tata name stands for quality and Nano can save a lot of lives.

    On the other hand, along with the abuandant supply of cars
    in India, if the road system is not develped in proportion to the
    car production, we are going to face serious problems of
    clogged roadways, wasted time, and road rage.

    Nano has a great potential to be in front of every home in
    the Western countries, to be used exclusively for getting to
    work and shopping.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s